Caster Semenya during the IAAF Champs in Berlin. AFP
No guarantee of secrecy
Fri, 20 Nov 2009 12:00
There is no guarantee that the results of a gender test
performed on athlete Caster Semenya will be kept confidential,
Sport and Recreation Minister Makhenkesi Stofile said on Thursday.
"We can never guarantee that," Stofile said, adding that the
origins of leaks about the gender tests on her had not been traced.
Stofile was responding to questions from the media about the
announcement of a deal between the government, Semenya's lawyers
and the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF).
As part of the agreement, Semenya will retain the gold medal she
won at the IAAF world competition in Berlin earlier this year, the
title of 800 metre champion, and her prize money.
Stofile said the IAAF would convene on Friday when the matter
would be formalised.
It would be a "breach of faith" if the IAAF did not agree to the
deal.
Prior to the August competition, questions had been raised about
Semenya's gender because of her masculine physique, deep voice and
powerful running style.
In an earlier statement the department said the IAAF agreed that
the tests done on Semenya would be treated as a confidential matter
between patient and doctor.
"As such there will be no public announcement of what the panel
of scientists has found," it said.
Stofile said the results could be conveyed to Semenya as early
as this weekend.
"We urge all South Africans and other people to respect this
professional, ethical and moral way of doing things."
The IAAF conducted a gender test on Semenya in Germany, to the
criticism of suspended Athletics South Africa (ASA) president
Leonard Chuene and local politicians, who accused the IAAF of
racism, sexism, eurocentricity and colonialism.
Chuene later admitted that ASA had conducted its own gender test
on Semenya before she left for Germany. He has been suspended over
the debacle.
In September, an Australian newspaper reported an as yet
unconfirmed leak that the IAAF had found Semenya was a
hermaphrodite. Semenya was reportedly "devastated" about the
article.
The IAAF had described Semenya's treatment as "deeply
regrettable", the department of sport and recreation said in a
statement.
"The IAAF is adamant that the public discourse did not originate
with them," the department said.
"We also cannot prove the contrary. It is our considered view
that this chapter of blame-apportioning must now be closed."
The department said that, after deliberations with the IAAF and
Semenya's lawyers, it was decided that the runner was blameless in
the controversy and should keep the prizes she won in Berlin.
The department criticised the ASA under Chuene and endorsed the
South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (Sascoc),
which took over the administration of ASA after the suspension of
Chuene and the board. A new board is to be elected over the
weekend.
It said it had spoken to involved parties from the start,
despite many challenges.
"This [discussion] was not easy given the sensitivity of the
issues as well as the distance between us and the sport bodies. The
IAAF is in Europe; ASA is in South Africa, but were harder to get
the facts from," the department said.
"Perhaps Sascoc was better in getting closer to the truth,
because they started the quest for the truth later than all of us."
Asked how Semenya was taking the news that she could retain her
Berlin gains, Stofile was sure she was "excited".
"She will roll with the punches. In my view Caster Semenya's
future is in her hands. She can decide to run as a girl, which she
is," he said.