More refs at 2010?
Tue, 01 Dec 2009 12:00
After Thierry Henry's deliberate handball put France in the
World Cup and eliminated Ireland, FIFA will decide on Wednesday
whether to help referees with video technology or extra officials
at next year's tournament in South Africa.
Faced by a storm of protests that it wasn't doing enough to help
referees, FIFA's executive committee is holding an emergency
meeting in Cape Town two days ahead of the World Cup draw.
Ahead of what has turned out to be a vitally important meeting,
the game appears divided over what FIFA should do.
They can decide to do nothing, let the referees have the benefit
of the 26 or so TV cameras that surround the field, give the fourth
official a TV monitor or copy the Europa League experiment and have
an extra match official at either end of the field to help the
others.
David Dein, the former English Football Association vice
chairman who has become a leading consultant on the future of the
game, is a strong supporter of TV technology but believes FIFA will
go for the extra officials.
"Let's give the referees help. They actually want the help now,"
Dein said at the Soccerex business conference in Johannesburg.
"They'll put the two extra officials probably. It's already in the
Europa League as an experiment. Everybody's wired up and it will be
interesting to see how it works.
"Technology is a huge subject and it's been brought to the boil
by the Thierry Henry incident. You've got critical decisions at the
top level that affect the game so much. OK, they are looking at
extra officials but don't slam the door on technology."
Henry's handball while playing for France in last month's
qualifying playoff against Ireland set up an equalizer in a 1-1
draw which put the French through to the World Cup 2-1 on aggregate
and eliminated the Irish.
The incident was not spotted by Swedish referee Martin Hansson
and the goal stood even though millions saw TV replays of Henry
deliberately controlling the ball with his left arm and hand to
keep the ball in play.
FIFA rejected an Irish appeal for the game to replayed and
Wednesday's meeting of the executive committee will also hear
Ireland's request to add its name to the 32 teams already in the
draw.
That seems almost certain to be rejected, too, but FIFA still
has the task of finding better ways to avoid similar situations
happening again.
Gerard Houllier, who is technical director of the France
national team, doesn't want to see football take on the full extent
of TV technology but can see how it can help in small doses.
"I am very much in favor of goalline technology but I have mixed
feelings about video technology in general," Houllier said Tuesday.
"I am very reluctant because you can't have 26 cameras at a game in
the Faeroe Islands. And you have to leave the referee to know the
game and to interpret.
"With the Thierry Henry handball as an example, the fourth
official should have a monitor. He should never talk to the referee
but, in some circumstances, the main referee could ask him through
the microphone if there was something controversial he couldn't
see."
The handball debate is not the only matter on the agenda of the
executive committee. FIFA also wants to discuss the latest wave of
match-fixing and betting scams coming out of central and eastern
Europe. It is also concerned that the playoff systems used for the
World Cup may have given some of the teams an advantage.
The playoffs in Europe involved eight of the group runners-up
playing against each other home and away. Blatter believes that,
because one country then gets the advantage of playing the second
leg at home, that becomes unfair and FIFA will look at the playoffs
being just one game on neutral turf.